Each case is a standalone investigation. Pick the one that calls to you, gather your group, and begin.
A body washes ashore in Edgartown Harbor. What first appears to be a tragic accident begins to come apart almost immediately. Statements don't line up. Small details refuse to s...
Coming Soon
Coming September 2026. The next file is in development. A new investigation, rooted in another corner of the island. Sign up to the newsletter to hear the moment it opens.
Coming Soon
Coming 2027. A third investigation is on the horizon. Sign up to the newsletter to hear the moment it opens.
Three marks are concealed across this site. Find all three and a sealed case opens, with 5% off your first case file waiting inside.
Look for the ◆.
